Update the MATSim network file for Mount Alexander Shire about bdi-abm-integration

[dhixsingh]

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Nagel Kai
Date: 12 December 2017 at 10:45
Subject: Bradford
To: Dhirendra Singh

Dear Dhirendra,

I should have sent this email before the other one.

They are always taking the "long" route, even before the fire is there. See below.

Reason is that your "secondary" road have speed 16.66 (=60km/h), while your tertiary roads have speed 27.77 (=100km/h). (The "unclassified" roads, which again one level below that, have 12.5 (=45km/h).)

We had originally not really defined the base road characteristics of our OSM reader, assuming that they would vary from region to region anyways. As is typical, everybody was and is just using the default values. Some of us have now tried to put in some more reasonable default values. Maybe you want to re-import your networks at some point, with the newest MATSim OSMReader.

I have actually seen more weirdnesses in your network, such as links with speed infinity (am setting those to a speed of 9999999999. in MATSimModel to make the router work).

Am "correcting" it in various ways inside matsimmodel, but maybe at some point you may want to clean up your input data.

Best wishes

Kai

[dhixsingh]

Should also change the scenarios/tests to link to a single network file so that it is then easier to update it in the one place. Right now each scenario saves its own copy. Raised #9 for this.

[dhixsingh]

Commit b9cc923 contains the updated network file mount_alexander_shire_network_20180206.xml.gz, that was created as follows:

osmosis --rb file=AU.pbf --bounding-box top=-36.8758 left=143.8344 bottom=-37.2762 right=144.5533 completeWays=true --used-node --wb mas-allroads.osm.pbf

osmosis --rb file=AU.pbf --bounding-box top=-33.184 left=138.208 bottom=-39.215 right=151.776 --tf accept-ways highway=motorway,motorway_link,trunk,trunk_link,primary,primary_link --used-node --wb mas-bigroads.osm.pbf

osmosis --rb file=mas-allroads.osm.pbf --rb file=mas-bigroads.osm.pbf --merge --wx mas-merged-network.osm 

mvn exec:java -Dexec.mainClass="io.github.agentsoz.util.NetworkGenerator" -Dexec.args="-i ./scenarios/mount-alexander-shire/mas-merged-network.osm -o ./scenarios/mount-alexander-shire/mount_alexander_shire_network_20180206.xml"

Tests have not been updated to use this yet, as the link IDs have all changed and the network change event files used by tests will no longer work. Probably easiest is to just remove the network change event files, and after visual inspection, accept the new results one by one.

[dhixsingh]

Commit 91ed456 contains as updated file mount_alexander_shire_network_2018.xml.gz with the Mount Alexander Shire MATSim network. There is also a new script create-mas-network.sh that automates the process.

[dhixsingh]

Note the OpenStreetMap recommendation for tagging in Australia.

Also, the current recommended maxspeed defaults for Australia are reproduced below.

highway=motorway - 100 km/h usually, 110 km/h only where sign-posted
highway=primary - 80 to 90 km/h
highway=secondary - 50 to 70 km/h
highway=tertiary - 50 km/h
highway=residential - 50 km/h, usually 40 km/h in school zones

These should be reflected in NetworkGenerator that currently has:

bdi-abm-integration/util/src/main/java/io/github/agentsoz/util/NetworkGenerator.java

Lines 90 to 104 in 91ed456

	// Explicitly specify the defaults for Australian roads
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(1, "motorway", 2, 110.0/3.6, 1.0, 2000, true);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(1, "motorway_link", 1, 80.0/3.6, 1.0, 1500, true);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(2, "trunk", 1, 80.0/3.6, 1.0, 2000);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(2, "trunk_link", 1, 50.0/3.6, 1.0, 1500);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(3, "primary", 1, 80.0/3.6, 1.0, 1500);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(3, "primary_link", 1, 60.0/3.6, 1.0, 1500);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(4, "secondary", 1, 30.0/3.6, 1.0, 1000);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(4, "secondary_link", 1, 30.0/3.6, 1.0, 1000);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(5, "tertiary", 1, 25.0/3.6, 1.0, 600);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(5, "tertiary_link", 1, 25.0/3.6, 1.0, 600);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(6, "unclassified", 1, 15.0/3.6, 1.0, 600);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(7, "residential", 1, 15.0/3.6, 1.0, 600);
	onr.setHighwayDefaults(8, "living_street", 1, 10.0/3.6, 1.0, 300);

[dhixsingh]

Since 2804a23 Maldon100WithEmergencyVehiclesTest uses the new network. Will raise a separate issue for updating other tests as needed.

[dhixsingh]

Attached are some views of the final network. Colours represent freespeed:

• 110 km/h is dark blue
• 90-100 km/h is light blue
• 60-80 km/hr is yellow
• 50 km/h and lower is red

Here is the full extent of the new network:

Here is the same network zoomed into the area of detail:

Some issues in the underlying OSM network are evident. In the zoomed view, the patch of blue roads in the top left (west of Bendigo), suggests inconsistencies in mapping data--those roads have been tagged with a speed limit of ``100 km/h` whereas other likely similar nearby roads are not. The extent of the problems is not clear and requires further investigation.

Mount Alexander Shire Municipal Fire Management Planning Committee is aware of the OSM issues, and till such that that we can commit resources to investigating these further, we will accept this network for ongoing work.