Please document how to use `#[deno_bindgen]` when embedding about deno_bindgen

[littledivy]

deno_bindgen is for runtime FFI. For embedding usecases, you should use deno_ops: https://github.com/denoland/deno_core/tree/main/ops

An example can be found here: https://github.com/denoland/deno_core/blob/main/core/examples/hello_world.rs

The repository for issues related to deno_ops is denoland/deno_core

[joshtriplett]

@littledivy I had already looked at deno_ops (and for that matter the version exported from deno_core as op2). That makes it very easy to export individual functions from Rust to Deno. However, that then requires writing a JS or TS module that wraps those ops, to provide types and methods. What I was hoping for was the ability to export an ES6 module from Rust, similarly to what deno_bindgen provides or what rquickjs provides, without having to write those two wrappers (a Rust wrapper for each method exposing it as a function, and a JS/TS wrapper for each function turning it back into a method).

Ideally, I'd love to write something like this,:

#[deno_core::something(my_es6_module)]
mod my_module {
    #[deno_core::something_else]
    struct SomeType {
        field: Type,
    }

    #[deno_core::something]
    impl SomeType {
        fn new() -> Self { todo!() }
        fn method(&self, arg: Abc) { todo!() }
        fn another_method(&mut self, arg: Xyz) { todo!() }
    }

    // optionally some module initialization code, other types, constants, functions, etc
}

my_es6_module::init_ops_and_esm()

Right now, if I already have that type, I have to write three ops, export those in an extension, and write a JS/TS file defining a type with methods wrapping those three ops.

Is this something that just doesn't exist today? Is anything like this on the roadmap?

[bartlomieju]

Hey @joshtriplett. Something like this currently doesn't exist. Not sure about the roadmap at the moment, but I know that both @littledivy and @mmastrac have been discussion something like that as a potential new feature. So unfortunately for now you'll have to resort to writing the JS/TS glue code.

[mmastrac]

I've got some ideas on how we can extend our op system to do that. We're not too far off, and we recently landed the first bits of support for cpp_gc which was the last missing piece to integrate with GC.