Thanks for promoting umm_malloc about umm_malloc

[dimonomid]

Hello Ralph, nice to hear from you!

Yeah, since I found umm_malloc I use it in my every embedded project, it is really great. Thank you very much for your hard work on it.

That's great that you've created your own repo, so that allocator could be improved even more! And about testing - ironically enough, I'm myself learning testing framework (in particular, CppUTest) for my embedded designs these days. It looks promising, its author even wrote the book, in case you're interested: Test Driven Development for Embedded C

About pulling changes: of course I'm glad to hear that, please let me know if you're waiting for me to do something (I'm not sure how exactly changes could be pulled from my repo to yours, should I do something for that?)

[almania]

Hi both,

Firstly, neat allocator, was looking for an open source one aimed at embedded devices and this is just great.

Secondly.. there's a bug. In umm_realloc: on a malloc failure, it frees the original pointer. The standard assures this not to be the case, and Lua assumes this too (eg when reallocing hash tables, it assumes data isn't lost/corrupt should an expansion fail).

The fix is very straight forward - just move umm_free( oldptr) in umm_realloc to the same block as the memcpy.

The bug is present both here and on @rhempel's website.

HTH and thanks again for making it available here :)

[rhempel]

Technically, this should be a new issue :-) Side note, are you using this allocator in an embedded Kua implementation - that's what I wrote it for in the first place! If I get a chance, I'll fix on my site...

[almania]

I figured it should be after I posted, I was just too eager when I saw you both in one place ;). My first time using github.

And I am, I saw that on your site too - one of the things that drew me to it. Lua 5.2, which includes an emergency garbage collector in case of OOM which allows the allocator to run closer to the limit (I believe most embedded are Lua 5.1.X?), probably why it hasn't popped up before. Working great now though :)

[rhempel]

Well, I'm using it for Lua as well, on the LEGO MINDSTORMS NXT - and I was having an issue occasionally when the garbage collector had to run - maybe this is related - actually it's very likely related. Thks for the report. I am more focused on ev3dev.org (Debian Jessie on LEGO MINDSTROMS EV3) right now, but I will definitely look at this when I have time

[TheBigFish]

Hello everyone.
This library is exactly what I need.Thank you very much!