How to make it work with torch DDP about ipyparallel

[mosesnyamai]

I completely agree that debugging code for parallel training can be incredibly challenging, and the idea of being able to work on it in a notebook is certainly appealing. Thank you for bringing up this important issue.

…

On Thu, Jun 22, 2023 at 6:43 PM Xie Zejian ***@***.***> wrote: Debugging code for parallel training is very painful, and it would be very appealing to be able to do it in a notebook. — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#813>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AJBYOE2NR2YQC6QFLIS7V53XMRRYLANCNFSM6AAAAAAZQMYC5E> . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[minrk]

Got it. I don't think there's any feature request here, but perhaps an example or some docs. I don't know much about torch or what ddp is, but if you can provide some examples of how workers are started with it, I may be able to give a hint to how to get them into IPython Parallel. Usually the easiest way is to start IPython Parallel and then run whatever startup code the workers use in the IPython session.

The second way is to use some code injection to launch an IPython interpreter in each worker after they are launched in whatever way your tool usually does. That's all the information I can give without knowing anything about the situation.

[minrk]

Is there a task here? I'm not sure why this has been opened as an issue on this repo.

You can use IPython Parallel for a certain kind of debugging in parallel (it's not a debugger and certainly not a parallel debugger, which is very challenging), but it can be used to get an interactive interpreter in each of your worker processes for poking around.

[fecet]

Having an interactive interpreter during parallel training is already quite appealing, especially now that deep learning increasingly relies on a significant amount of resources. This could be a scenario where ipyparallel can shine.

This issue primarily serves as a feature request or question because initiating torch ddp requires some additional setup, which remains challenging for regular users like myself.