[JENKINS-10364] Publish over FTP Plugin loses configuration when unchecking the box about publish-over-ftp-plugin

[jira-importer]

bap:

I can think of a couple of ways to achieve this with the current version of the plugin

The first is to install the promoted-builds plugin
During the build, "Archive the artifacts" that you want to FTP
Create a promotion that has an action that performs the FTP
You can then easily switch between manual promotion or automatically promoting (the build can promote itself!)
This also has the advantage that any given build can be promoted (FTP'd) at any given time (eg rollback - if #34 has been sent, but is bad, #32 could easily be sent back accross by re-executing the promotion)

The other way is to use the new parameterized publishing feature
Set a parameter name in the Advanced options of the publisher, and make the build parameterized with a parameter of the same name
You can use a String parameter or choice to select between the two options below
.* will publish to all FTP servers
.+ will publish to all FTP servers that have a label (as you have not given any labels, this would mean that none would publish)
Set the default parameter value for builds that are started automatically

A skip option also feels like it should be a lot more generic than just adding to every plugin - they are all configured in the same manner, and they all loose their configs if disabled and the config saved.

Would either of the above (especially the promoted-builds solution) be acceptable?

[jira-importer]

jacob_robertson:

Put yourself in my situation: I have two hundred jobs, each with an associated release job. I would like development teams to maintain their own jobs, but my team ends up providing assistance for all the jobs. The actual build steps in the jobs are already complicated (but as simple as we could make them), so we've worked really hard to try and keep all configuration down as much as possible, including writing our own in-house plugins that wrap up some configuration, etc. So, although what you described seems fine, it doesn't help me keep this simple for the development teams.

I do agree that having a generic skip would have been a nice thing for Jenkins to have built into the framework. I see it kind of like the maven skip facility - each plugin had to roll its own, and not all of them have that capability. But in retrospect, maven should have made this easy also. Meanwhile, it is what it is.

[jira-importer]

bap:

Jacob,

I have just released the Flexible Publish Plugin https://wiki.jenkins-ci.org/display/JENKINS/Flexible+Publish+Plugin (wiki page to become useful this afternoon )

With this plugin installed, you can add the "Send build artifacts over FTP" to the "Flexible publish" Post-build Action and use the Run Condition "Always" to enable the publish.

To "skip" without losing the FTP configuration, update the Run Condition to "Never".

Please close this issue if you find my solution acceptable.

Bap.

[jira-importer]

bap:

No response, assume happy