Sudden drop in computing performance? about stacknet

[goldentom42]

I'm also on Ubuntu 16.04 LTS I can give it a try if you wish.

[kaz-Anova]

@arisbw .

You dont need to remove it . You just change the seed of Softmax to 10 it works fine:

softmaxnnclassifier usescale:True seed:10 Type:SGD maxim_Iteration:35 C:0.0005 learn_rate:0.001 smooth:0.0001 h1:50 h2:40 connection_nonlinearity:Relu init_values:0.05 verbose:false

Honestly I have not a single clue why...
These are the results of all models:

Average of all folds model 0 : 0.7867379723430724
 Average of all folds model 1 : 0.7929649557885149
 Average of all folds model 2 : 0.7866359111370649
 Average of all folds model 3 : 0.7764824969782087
 Average of all folds model 4 : 0.7805320681382869
 Average of all folds model 5 : 0.7754102012289547
 Average of all folds model 6 : 0.7642405924462954
 Average of all folds model 7 : 0.7817682598159342

[kaz-Anova]

I have seen that before in windows...Strangely if you just press enter into the screen it continues. Not sure why this happens.... Can you try that and let me know?

[arisbw]

Already tried it but nothing happened.

[arisbw]

Strangely enough, this event also occurred when I ran the code from ubuntu 16.04.

[kaz-Anova]

That is indeed strange. I have not seen that before... Does it always hang at the same place ? could you send me the file you run this and the parameters' file (as well as the command you run) and tell me where I should expect the pause in order to try and replicate?

[arisbw]

Thanks guys. Here are the files. You will expect sudden drop in 5th fold of first layer (4th model).

[goldentom42]

ok got the files. just started stacknet on win8.1 and will let you know.

[arisbw]

If you happen to produce output file, could you please send it back to me? Thanks.

[goldentom42]

Yeh sure ;-)
By the way looking at the param file I saw that RandomForest had 5 threads when you have 4 logical cores. Did you try reducing that number?
I'm just wondering if StackNet is not waiting for that thread to complete.
This may sound completely stupid but never know...

[arisbw]

Ah I see. You seem right, but it should break at first fold, right? But now I try to run it again with modified threads params.

[goldentom42]

Issue reproduced. perf drops at 30% on the 5th fold and 4 first models.
3 metrics are displayed but not the 4th one.

[goldentom42]

Reducing the number of threads does not change the problem. However after reducing the number of estimators or iterations of the models I managed to get StackNet go through the all process...

[arisbw]

OK. Could you please share that modified params?

[kaz-Anova]

I am also running it right now and will let you know the results . I have many cores available and did not encounter a problem at 2nd fold (e.g. I am in 4th now) , which makes me think this is in general related with threading...

[kaz-Anova]

It is reproduced. Don't know why , but it seems to be at the predict() of the Softmaxclassifier . The reason CPU stops is not relevant - it has to do with the fact that we are in scoring and threading is not used. For some reason there must be a bug the code causing an infinite loop somewhere.

It does not throw error though..

[kaz-Anova]

I will try to find a workaround.

[goldentom42]

@arisbw, the reduced estimators were really low like 3 or 4... so it won't help you.
As @kaz-Anova said above, you may want to remove softmaxclassifier for now.

[arisbw]

OK, I'll make sure to remove softmaxclassifier for now. Thank you @goldentom42 @kaz-Anova

[arisbw]

...... now it goes much weirder that I can imagine. Again, thanks @kaz-Anova!