Linux containers [LCOW] not working after tweaking instructions about lcow

[rn]

I made release two weeks ago (or so). Not planning to make one soon, unless there are more changes to OpenGCS, which is the main component running in the VM

[rn]

what's your version of the the docker daemon and CLI, ie output of docker version?

[riezebosch]

Have it working using this gist on Windows Server Core 1709 (OS version 10.0.16299.0).

[JensNordenbro]

I also cannot get LCOW to work on Windows Server 2019. I can see that your posts are ~½ year old and looking at your gist @riezebosch it seems to me that this is still an experimental feature although I have read at https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/get-started-19/whats-new-19 , paragraph "Linux containers on Windows":

"It is now possible to run Windows and Linux-based containers on the same container host, using the same docker daemon. This enables you to have a heterogenous container host environment while providing flexibility to application developers."

What are your thoughts on this, is it supported or not ?

[rn]

@JensNordenbro what's your error? I don't have access to a Windows machine anymore, but might be able to help. For more general questions on how to get LCOW to work with docker, moby/moby is a better repository to ask questions.

[JensNordenbro]

basically my machine says "no matching manifest for windows/amd64 in the manifest list entries."

I will try the experimental modes on another machine, but I find the whole information on LCOW support to be very confusing…

[rn]

When most of the initial instructions were written, LCOW was still very much under heavy development and having it behind --experimental means that the way users use it may change. I haven't followed the LCOW development for about 6 months and am not up to speed how it is now integrated with docker. You are probably better off asking on https://github.com/moby/moby what the current recommended way is.

[JensNordenbro]

@riezebosch ; I ran your gist-script and it worked until executing the Utility VM saying: Error response from daemon: failed to start service utility VM (createreadwrite): kernel 'C:\Program Files\Linux Containers\kernel' not found.

[rn]

@JensNordenbro have you copied the kernel and initrd there as suggested in the README.md from the line "Next, you need to get the LinuxKit images..." onwards?

[JensNordenbro]

yes, I think so since I have

• bootx63.efi
• initrd
• versions
  under "c:\Program Files\Linux Containers"

[lahma]

@JensNordenbro if you open the latest zip from https://github.com/linuxkit/lcow/releases/tag/v4.14.35-v0.3.9 you should see that there is a file named kernel. The naming changed recently. I suppose you have older release in use.

[JensNordenbro]

Now it works. Thanks @lahma, @rn!

So my conclusions are:

1. In order to enable LCOW a manual install is necessary.
2. This is not supported by Microsoft since it is --experimental

And since I am fetching docker(d).exe from master builds; It is not supported by Docker also?!

Am I right?!

[rn]

@JensNordenbro I can't answer the question of which version of docker(d) or Windows supports LCOW to what degree as I work for neither Docker nor Microsoft. It's probably a good question to ask initially on https://github.com/moby/moby which is where both Docker and Microsoft developing the upstream support are hanging out.

Closing this issue.

[JensNordenbro]

So as a final question @rn, when are you planning to make a Release branch out of your master branch the next time?