Wallet compatibility about robosats

[kaloudis]

Maintainer from Zeus here. We'll be adding support for hold invoices soon. You can track progress here: ZeusLN/zeus#865

[zehks]

LnTxBot tested on BUYING successfully.

The hold invoice is shown as a pending payment and shows a user-friendly text.

RoboSats - Publishing 'Order xxx: BUY BTC for xxx EUR' - Maker bond - This payment WILL FREEZE IN YOUR WALLET, check on the website if it was successful. It will automatically return unless you cheat or cancel unilaterally.

The TX details is shown as:

🕓 PENDING a 28 Feb 2022 at 1:48PM

RoboSats - Publishing 'Order xxx: BUY BTC for xxx EUR' - Maker bond - This payment WILL FREEZE IN YOUR WALLET, check on the website if it was successful. It will automatically return unless you cheat or cancel unilaterally.
Beneficiario: xxx(~)
Hash: xxx
Monto: -xxx sat (-xxx USD)
Tarifa pagada: 7.25 sat
Rutas probadas:
❌

If the invoice expires then it shows a failed payment message. It also shows a failed payment when it unfreezes at trade completion.

❌ Pago fallido. /log_e593b

And the log shows as:

Rutas probadas para xxx:
❌ incorrect payment details or unknown payment hash

In summary: good experience with LnTxBot on RoboSats

[openoms]

Tested the Bitcoin Wallet by being on both sides of the trade. Worked well.
The hodl invoice shows as a grey icon while waiting.
Need to tap the obvious back button to return to the main screen while the payment is pending.

Wallet	Version	Interface	Recognizes Hold	Misleading	Concurrent HTLCs	Compatibility	Recommended
Bitcoin Beach	v1.7.7 build 310	Mobile	No	No	Yes	Good	Yes

[ozoono]

CoinOS tested on BUYING successfully.

Hold invoice works (in Robosats you can see the fidelity bond is locked), but CoinOS shows a progress bar for the transaction for a couple of minutes, and finally it throws an error .

Payouts from Robosats receiving bought sats works fine

[marcusmv3]

Breez Wallet SELLING tested successfully. Have yet to test buying. Hold invoices seemed to work as intended.

[kobiebotha]

I tested paying the fidelity bond as a buyer using Cash App's lightning wallet, and it worked successfully. That is, the payment first showed as pending and then when the trade completed successfully, the send payment in Cash failed and I got the sats back. Bonus: I got a text message Cash App: Your payment of XX sats ($Y) failed. when the trade went through.

[editwentyone]

with latest phoenix 1.5.6 I only could create an offer with 06:00 + 02:55

other tests like 06:55 + 03:00 didn't work.

[RippedTrojan]

Breez wallet has worked without a hitch as a maker for both buy and sell transactions. It's also very convenient to use for beginners as it takes care of channel setup and balance for you (for a small fee, of course).

Wallet	Version	Device	UX	Bonds	Payout	Comp	Total
Breeze	1.0.19	Mobile	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Thumbs Up

[Tigerix]

Just tested Robosats with Electrum 4.3.0 on Testnet.
Everything worked flawlessly from offer to closing the deal!

[Reckless-Satoshi]

Just tested Robosats with Electrum 4.3.0 on Testnet.
Everything worked flawlessly from offer to closing the deal!

Did you take both sides of the trade with the same wallet? If so we should update the table to confirm Electrum is fully compatible.

[Tigerix]

Just tested Robosats with Electrum 4.3.0 on Testnet.
Everything worked flawlessly from offer to closing the deal!

Did you take both sides of the trade with the same wallet? If so we should update the table to confirm Electrum is fully compatible.

Yes, both sides with the same wallet!

[Reckless-Satoshi]

@editwentyone thanks for reporting, we can better nail this param now.

@RippedTrojan great to know, thank you! must be added to the docs:
https://github.com/Reckless-Satoshi/robosats/blob/2fd4a0123e82d1e68dd2ff90624921eb04d14b2a/docs/_pages/docs/03-understand/07-wallets.md?plain=1#L40-L44
Would you like to open a PR? (so your contribution is properly credited on next release)

[Reckless-Satoshi]

Closing. Please open a new issue if related to wallet compatibility or directly open a PR editing our wallet compatibility docs: http://learn.robosats.com/docs/wallets purse