ProviderScope override "forgets" the StreamProvider value during navigation about riverpod

[rrousselGit]

Oh, I know

It's the good-old "a provider is scoped to its route"

By using ProviderScope inside a route, the override is not accessible to other routes.

[rrousselGit]

Honestly, this is more of an issue with Overlay than riverpod. flutter/flutter#36220 should be fixed.
Ideally by merging flutter/flutter#39104

As for how to fix it... Maybe consume the value above the OpenContainer and re-override ProviderScope inside the builder with the true value

[rrousselGit]

In your case, this happens not because of navigation, but because of Overlay

During the transition, your Consumer is rendered above PageOne for a moment.

[RobertBrunhage]

Ohh I see but then what would be a good solution for that? As that value is used by both and I can not put it above the MaterialApp as let's say I have no access to the value there. (Getting the user after sign in).

It feels weird to wrap both the ClosedBuilder return value and the OpenBuilder return value with a override

[RobertBrunhage]

Yeah did that and it works, thanks for the help!

[samu-developments]

Honestly, this is more of an issue with Overlay than riverpod. flutter/flutter#36220 should be fixed.
Ideally by merging flutter/flutter#39104

As for how to fix it... Maybe consume the value above the OpenContainer and re-override ProviderScope inside the builder with the true value

Hi, I'm trying to implement this solution, however I'm getting this error:
Unsupported operation: ProviderScope was rebuilt with a different ProviderScope ancestor.
along with:

════════ Exception caught by widgets library ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════
Updated the list of overrides with providers that were not overriden before
'package:riverpod/src/framework/container.dart':
Failed assertion: line 247 pos 9: 'unusedOverrides.isEmpty'

final Widget closedScreen;

@override
  Widget build(BuildContext context) {
    return Consumer((context, watch) {
      final bool favorited = watch(favoritedProvider);
      return OpenContainer(
        closedBuilder: (_, __) {
          return ProviderScope(
            overrides: [
              favoritedProvider.overrideWithValue(favorited),
            ],
            child: closedScreen,
          );
        },
        openBuilder: (_, __) {
          return Container();
        },
      );
    });

The closedScreen builds fine on initial build, only during animation (when closedScreen is tapped) is the error thrown. What am I doing wrong? Thanks

flutter_riverpod: ^0.6.1
animations: ^1.1.2