Neat URL: Multiple errors of removing parameters from references. about firefoxaddons

[Smile4ever]

Hi. Could you provide me a valid link which demonstrates the problem?

[SCmkQrK1NhwcWoPJF3FImaqHnG2PqPLWBt2GtSU]

This is a valid link to a special standard test domain. There is no site, but you can replace "example.test" with "example.com". Or do you really need a link from real life from this site, which steals personal data in such a tricky way?

[Smile4ever]

Example.com will do for testing purposes, but is there actually a site which does something like this?

[SCmkQrK1NhwcWoPJF3FImaqHnG2PqPLWBt2GtSU]

"https://www.liveinternet.ru/users/acarabanow/post381600676/" page contains a link "https://www.liveinternet.ru/journal_proc.php?action=redirect&url=http://kleopatra0707.com/partner/2065401?utm_source=partner_kleo0707_2065401" with the "http://kleopatra0707.com/partner/2065401?utm_source=partner_kleo0707_2065401" title. (This page has nothing to do with me.)

[Smile4ever]

Thanks, I will look into this.

[crssi]

Hmmm... why not keep it simple and make it stronger at what it does best and leave to Neat URL just stripping parameters?
And for redirection use "Skip Redirect" instead?
IMHO

[Smile4ever]

I agree with crssi. Please use "Skip Redirect" for this purpose.

[SCmkQrK1NhwcWoPJF3FImaqHnG2PqPLWBt2GtSU]

"Skip Redirect" for other purposes. "Skip Redirect" handles the last example in a different way, with a different result. "Request Control" can replace your entire add-on, but it also has this error. I temporarily use "Redirector" - it solves this problem, but the regular expression is very inconvenient and big.

[SCmkQrK1NhwcWoPJF3FImaqHnG2PqPLWBt2GtSU]

In Neat URL 3.2.0 the second question mark spoils now, by the way.

[gwarser]

@SCmkQrK1NhwcWoPJF3FImaqHnG2PqPLWBt2GtSU if you are brave, and have bit of coding skills (compile this yourself) you can check my pull request #82

Of course, this is only draft, and needs cleaning/linting, but works for me right now.