not working (conflict with clang-formatter in cpptool package) about vscode-astyle

[BillDenton]

With the latest version of you can disable the CLangFormat using:
Added option to disable clang-format-based formatting provided by this extension via "C_Cpp.formatting" : "disabled"
I've not tried it.

[welkineins]

Hi pollow,

It seems that currently vscode has no configuration for choosing language code formatting provider, but I notice that the latest installed provider will be the default one.

You can uninstall and install astyle again to fix the problem for now. At the mean time, I'll looking for other solutions, e.g. provide different context menu option or keymap to trigger astyle formatter.

Thank you.

[pollow]

Thanks for your reply and your great work! I'll try to work around to solve
this problem.

On Mon, Oct 31, 2016, 10:23 PM Chieh Yu [email protected] wrote:

Hi pollow,

It seems that currently vscode has no configuration for choosing language
code formatting provider, but I notice that the latest installed provider
will be the default one.

You can uninstall and install astyle again to fix the problem for now. At
the mean time, I'll looking for other solutions, e.g. provide different
context menu option or keymap to trigger astyle formatter.

Thank you.

—
You are receiving this because you authored the thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
#3 (comment),
or mute the thread
https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABZHbgJaoLOflpSaDID_d5K_AjIvz-IWks5q5qKFgaJpZM4KkgU-
.

[welkineins]

Thanks to @BillDenton to provide a good solution for this issue. :)

I studied the VS code API, it's not support dominating formatter for one language. If you have multiple formatter with same match score, the later loaded one would be used.

Reference

• https://code.visualstudio.com/Docs/extensionAPI/vscode-api

[BillDenton]

I don't think the disable works in C++/C extension. I've reported an issue microsoft/vscode-cpptools#469. So far I haven't managed to get Astyle formatting even after disabling the whole of the C++/C extension.

[BillDenton]

I was using the wrong way of disabling CLangFormat. It should be:
"C_Cpp.formatting": "disabled",
Now just got to get some Astyle options that I'm happy with!