more and more channels are disabled although i see no reason why ... except i have been running charge-lnd for 3 weeks now. about charge-lnd

[chmeulblu]

yep. done more testing. i did have another app playing,nwith the fees : bos GUI that i though was not working on a scheduled mode , but was.. every 12h. that explained a lot. charge-lnd working as expected.

[accumulator]

It depends on your policies. Post the output of charge-lnd -v

[chmeulblu]

Hi,
thanks for reaching !
i think charge-lnd is a powerfull tool and has no equivalent. i am just seeing things i don't understand .

here is the story i hope it will help you understand more my context.
i have been reading as much as possible , looking at all examples i could find and finaly running experiments with the charge-lnd config files. and got to something i though was quite ok for my node ( 60 channels).

i installed charge-lng on a dedicated python env on my node. i sue crontab to run a bash shell it every hour.
the shell start the environnement
record the time of running , run charge-lnd redirecting outputs to a text file, close the environnement
i also wrote a python program to analyse the traces ( sort them by nodes. to see what happens overtime with a specific channel)

so, charge-lnd runs every hour...

after some days i noticed strange things in the traces. some nodes are sometimes appearing with the enable caracteristic although i don't see how they could have been disabled. so why writing enable since there should have been no modifications... were they disabled somehow whitout me ordering it ? ( if so disable would have appeared on the traces)

i then noticed on amboss space that some channels , more that it should, were disabled on my side. i got worried when it reached 1/3 on my channels.
so last night I replaced the more complicated config file with a very short one :

[default]
strategy = proportional
base_fee_ppm = 0
min_fee_ppm = 40
max_fee_ppm = 200
min_fee_ppm_delta = 0

whose goal was to re enable the disabled channel applying a default policy that when running on all nodes will automatically re enable them. (that is what i understood about charge-lnd behavior, through some reading)

i ran it several time and it looks like it did it for a few of them. not all. so i let it running every hour.
by the morning i had 2/3 of my channels disabled on my side and for most of them disabled on the peer side also ! ( a consequences of my disabling my side ? does the peer node sees things ? or the protocol ? and adapt ?)

i got then very worried . I restarted umbrel and .. got back online my channels. i commented out the call to charge-lnd in crontab since.

as i said this might have been just be a follow up of my previous setting who has been running for longer. here it is . 3 parts

• specific channels . that grew a bit over time. around 10 /60
• new channels
• the rest for which a global scheme is applied

---

some policies for very specific channels

------------------------------------------

[specific channels that do not update with charge-lnd and pollute ]

X does not respond to charge-lnd change requests. we bypass it

chan.id = 772654x1837x0, 774647x253x0, 812588x971x0

strategy = ignore

[other specific channels - too small... which pollute because they update every hour]
chan.id = 809131x2095x0

strategy = disable

[other specific channels - to prevent failed htlc]

because quite a few failed htlcs noticed using LNDg

chan.id = 810494x1350x7,810525x2097x5
chan.max_ratio = 0.015

strategy = disable

[specific-nodes]

for greedy nodes, we apply a proportional strategy with higher fees

chan.id = 811244x1555x0, 772652x1430x1, 811704x2659x1
chan.min_ratio = 0.1
chan.max_ratio = 0.9

strategy = proportional
min_fee_ppm = 300
max_fee_ppm = 1000

for young nodes

---------------------

[baby-channel-just created]

for brand new channels less than 12 blocks old (2 hours)

we initialize the defaults

chan.max_age = 12

strategy = static
base_fee_msat = 0
fee_ppm = 2000
time_lock_delta = 144
max_htlc_msat_ratio = 0.7
min_htlc_msat = 1000
min_fee_ppm_delta = 9

[new-channel baby -> 2 days full-recover-cost]

for channels we created less than 2 days ago (and no longer baby)

we make sure we'll cover at least (or almost) the opening and closing costs

chan.max_age = 288
chan.initiator = true

strategy = cost
cost_factor = 1

[new-channel from 2d -> 5d medium-recover-cost]

for channels we created between 2 days and 5 days

we still protect ourselves a bit

chan.max_age = 720
chan.initiator = true

strategy = cost
cost_factor = 0.5

-----------------------------------------

general policy, for other channels

-----------------------------------------

[emptied-channels]

on channels emptied (less than 80k of outbound available) I first disabled the channel but changed it to boost base fee to prevent disabling. before that it was the disable strategy.

chan.max_local_balance = 80000

strategy = static
base_fee_msat = 1111

[drained-channel-prevent-failed-routing]

on nearly emptied channels (less than 5% of outbound available) i first capped the maxhtlc . i then switch to base fee also

chan.max_ratio = 0.05

strategy = static
base_fee_msat = 10

#[low-outbound-channel-prevent-failed-routing]

on channels with low outbound (less than 15% of outbound available) same : first tried maxhtlc, then switched to base fee

#chan.max_ratio = 0.15

#strategy = static
#base_fee_msat = 2

[small-nodes]

we set up appropriate proportional fees

node.max_capacity = 100000000

strategy = proportional
min_fee_ppm = 0
max_fee_ppm = 55
max_htlc_msat_ratio = 0.7

[medium-nodes]

we set up appropriate proportional fees

node.max_capacity = 500000000

strategy = proportional
min_fee_ppm = 40
max_fee_ppm = 100
max_htlc_msat_ratio = 0.7

[large-nodes]

we set up appropriate proportional fees

up to 20 BTC

node.max_capacity = 20000000000

strategy = proportional
min_fee_ppm = 50
max_fee_ppm = 250
max_htlc_msat_ratio = 0.7

[giga-nodes]

we set up appropriate proportional fees

up to 100 BTC. we protect against draining for now same strategy as big nodes

node.max_capacity == 1000000000000

strategy = proportional
min_fee_ppm = 100
max_fee_ppm = 800
max_htlc_msat_ratio = 0.7

---

well a long long answer but if that is usefull to you and help understand i ll be very happy. i d like going on using charge-lnd.
please ask question if not clear or informatiosn are missing

[accumulator]

Please also post the output of charge-lnd -v

[chmeulblu]

and here is an extract of outputs i got during the night with the small config file. for one of the channel 👍

Heure: 06-12-23 01:00:01
| fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 74
| max_htlc_msat: 600000000 ➜ 2078999999

Heure: 06-12-23 02:00:01
    | channel status:  enabled
    | fee_ppm:         74
    | max_htlc_msat:   2078999999

Heure: 06-12-23 13:00:01
    | fee_ppm:         100 ➜ 72
    | max_htlc_msat:   600000000 ➜ 2078999999

Heure: 07-12-23 00:55:16
    | policy:          default
    | fee_ppm:         72 ➜ 122

Heure: 07-12-23 01:00:01
    | fee_ppm:         100 ➜ 126

Heure: 07-12-23 04:00:01
    | fee_ppm:         126 ➜ 125

Heure: 07-12-23 05:00:01
    | fee_ppm:         125 ➜ 124

Heure: 07-12-23 07:00:01
    | channel status:  enabled
    | fee_ppm:         124 ➜ 125

---

it goes enabled at 2 AM . why is it enabled again a 7 am ?

[accumulator]

The channel can be disabled by LND itself too (e.g. if the peer goes offline). charge-lnd requests the channel to be enabled, but LND can overrule this.

[chmeulblu]

and here some traces of before (long config files).
comments and policies are in french but are easy to understand i hope :

Execution time: 06-12-2023 02:00:01
813363x2757x2 [splurfyn0de|0201bfc5d9c14d50ebaf4dfd83d70df314ed2a9f0119f28619f3f000a1079ef580]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 48
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
811127x2015x1 [μi|0208dfa005c47a8ae85363d12c54007a38550ca0d6f1c559ee11caaac8221eccd6]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 155
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
784622x343x0 [i'llTryAnythingOnce|020d1617e27ac022395352f2b3774969593d3d6ddff6fb117d820a9dda8da45217]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 106
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
804940x2112x0 [node on the boat⛵|02103f1826be6287c8430e653de06ef16d94b3106c01937a78f5ae2c89bd40f234]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 49500
799390x1545x1 [DorianIsMySatoshi|021d2436cab847373a4212bf6d754ead5304f5d0791479643893a837b295f3441c]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 82
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
819321x848x1 [OGAF|022eedc8acac04e78faa75053458dabfc1b711b67854caac3dd3443f1a0b9e25a2]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 87
max_htlc_msat: 2772000000
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 42
max_htlc_msat: 346846500
770238x1242x0 [JayhawkPleb|0230e8b298bef620df9640c7a956106f905dbc48d5cedadd5837f3a22a9cdced28]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 42
max_htlc_msat: 3118500000
808648x1876x1 [NoVa_Helo_Bubba|02327617d2b6b397450dba550bd61f6fe1e4586af07b61af636211588b958f3e74]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 7920
770859x999x0 [Frode-lightning|023bdd219b85d02da9b3fd679b32a1098c97122767433eb4ba59641514bbcbd694]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 9900
813369x973x1 [MerchantConnectHUB|023e09c43b215bd3dbf483bcb409da3322ea5ea3b046f74698b89ee9ea785dd30a]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 62
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
786488x653x1 [CoinGate|0242a4ae0c5bef18048fbecf995094b74bfb0f7391418d71ed394784373f41e4f3]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 51
max_htlc_msat: 3465007000
811236x1782x1 [chilman|0242c1650f320c43f3600ebf3b5fcaf566760fcd421f35b68fd1e39a31b29ef540]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 91
max_htlc_msat: 3465000000
812524x502x1 [wobloz|025e9497188d33af48bb15cfc3cd6d7c549eed05b5f54d45615d3cb7ec3b562588]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 113
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
769802x1805x1 [028ed7bd6ba6763cf040|028ed7bd6ba6763cf040869681890bf5bf95d623108a60e75d76a57f5d637be3ef]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 46
max_htlc_msat: 3465000000
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 198000000
813229x358x1 [Azteco|02abfbe63425b1ba4f245af72a0a85ba16cd13365704655b2abfc13e53ad338e02]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 52
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
770256x803x1 [8DegreesWO|02b21ca992bf95e3f324302265ad86cec24f36166fd7afca44efa0809aaa8b25c5]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 52
max_htlc_msat: 3118500000
772652x1430x1 [Kraken 🐙⚡|02f1a8c87607f415c8f22c00593002775941dea48869ce23096af27b0cfdcc0b69]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 29700
819400x4180x1 [WCC-BOUNCER|02f4c77dcf12255ccf705c18b8d6b95e4f884910bf61e8aa21242607193a79da1b]
policy: new-canal de 2j -> 5j medium-recover-cost
strategy: cost
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 840
799591x324x1 [BitcoinMX 21M|031ea699f2f5e657473fd14302d00ea8018c67fa83403810544f5bd227b1cd2c41]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 79
max_htlc_msat: 2772000000
799489x248x1 [FranksNODE|032141e1142e05ea53fd7621b13c25db63a1e84102d7df18685024be4ad2dd5ca3]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 37
max_htlc_msat: 2772000000
809618x2972x0 [domesticblend|032b09fb582a7a0718a606ee075598b0ed2e04da376382db03d76aded6e56216c6]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 69
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999
810359x2574x0 [OverDrive|032d35946ccc4b303dd57836ad10ec1f95a0bac91c0c07f2f20d8445da939ff04e]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 495000000
811252x626x1 [GeldBoerse|032f46d1e9a0c0db99cf788ddfd86d815be6e9d752af37f4cef5a13a5276af7004]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 74
max_htlc_msat: 5197500000
783032x921x1 [xmrk|033878501f9a4ce97dba9a6bba4e540eca46cb129a322eb98ea1749ed18ab67735]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 52
max_htlc_msat: 3849999999
812524x700x0 [Garlic🧄|033b63e4a9931dc151037acbce12f4f8968c86f5655cf102bbfa85a26bd4adc6d9]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 70
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
730402x2295x1 [bfx-lnd0|033d8656219478701227199cbd6f670335c8d408a92ae88b962c49d4dc0e83e025]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 60390
791861x2577x1 [⚡️MasterYoda⚡|033dee9c6a0afc40ffd8f27d68ef260f3e5e1c19e59c6f9bb607fb04c1d497a809]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 72
max_htlc_msat: 5544000000
767259x696x0 [🗲 Greasedlightning 🗲|0351fabd839e93962826ab8eff7f86795b66b7295a2330773938d409a725aa8176]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 64
max_htlc_msat: 3465000000
811244x1555x0 [WalletOfSatoshi.com|035e4ff418fc8b5554c5d9eea66396c227bd429a3251c8cbc711002ba215bfc226]
policy: specific-nodes
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 372
806376x2004x22[LQwD-Canada|0364913d18a19c671bb36dd04d6ad5be0fe8f2894314c36a9db3f03c2d414907e1]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800
811704x2659x1 [Orange Sunrise|037943defcf3068fc5b8a2b821cdd2c4c1b1faa39d6a971b3fd984b9dd291a4817]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 50490
810807x2639x1 [tankman|0386d289121dc56f2b295c6dc8c7d0e4a7b3eb6d9b6b737a169b6360a81b9e9279]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 82
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
809630x812x0 [TPF_CLN|03b8d3617af7a3b525f2ca3cad9d08cae6ff7519a19c9cf3236b3b4e2f092087f4]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 73
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999
812523x1413x2 [Yankee Hotel Foxtrot|03d6f80df785288de2fe5de19f24ba8a1db3d20647a88d0a903be9de3e7bb8fce1]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 86
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
804951x1129x0 [<script>alert("LDK");</script>|03db10aa09ff04d3568b0621750794063df401e6853c79a21a83e1a3f3b5bfb0c8]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 247500000
729144x2302x0 [TheSovereignNode|03ded19c55ab1726e2b839e006321c002c61602cced485c75db895ec73fb48543a]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 72
max_htlc_msat: 1386000000
811604x2935x1 [bitmax|03e121fa397cb7ec60935c140bfbfa7690c3158ba6df26b8bc636508d8a3735afd]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000
805674x2868x0 [BTC Nigeria|03e86afe389d298f8f53a2f09fcc4d50cdd34e2fbd8f32cbd55583c596413705c2]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 7920000
774990x731x0 [Fi4free|03eb9f088f62bb414b74b11e287624d5f05fd92b582658b47b4ed6048e0dd01404]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000
770484x1645x1 [AliensTech|03f2005837649dd49811bbb7e78993581da41c09d3bdcbc6933492276acccd8b6d]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 74
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999

Execution time: 06-12-2023 03:00:01
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 198000000 ➜ 39600

Execution time: 06-12-2023 04:00:01
811127x2015x1 [μi|0208dfa005c47a8ae85363d12c54007a38550ca0d6f1c559ee11caaac8221eccd6]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 155 ➜ 166
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
809618x2972x0 [domesticblend|032b09fb582a7a0718a606ee075598b0ed2e04da376382db03d76aded6e56216c6]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 69 ➜ 59
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999

Execution time: 06-12-2023 05:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 06:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 07:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 08:00:01
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 346846500 ➜ 4954
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 39600 ➜ 7920000

Execution time: 06-12-2023 09:00:01
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 42
max_htlc_msat: 4954 ➜ 346846500

Execution time: 06-12-2023 10:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 11:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 12:00:01
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 50490

Execution time: 06-12-2023 13:00:01
813363x2757x2 [splurfyn0de|0201bfc5d9c14d50ebaf4dfd83d70df314ed2a9f0119f28619f3f000a1079ef580]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
811127x2015x1 [μi|0208dfa005c47a8ae85363d12c54007a38550ca0d6f1c559ee11caaac8221eccd6]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 166
max_htlc_msat: 2000000000 ➜ 6930000000
784622x343x0 [i'llTryAnythingOnce|020d1617e27ac022395352f2b3774969593d3d6ddff6fb117d820a9dda8da45217]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 106
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
804940x2112x0 [node on the boat⛵|02103f1826be6287c8430e653de06ef16d94b3106c01937a78f5ae2c89bd40f234]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 500000 ➜ 49500
799390x1545x1 [DorianIsMySatoshi|021d2436cab847373a4212bf6d754ead5304f5d0791479643893a837b295f3441c]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 82
max_htlc_msat: 2000000000 ➜ 6930000000
819321x848x1 [OGAF|022eedc8acac04e78faa75053458dabfc1b711b67854caac3dd3443f1a0b9e25a2]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 87
max_htlc_msat: 800000000 ➜ 2772000000
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 42
max_htlc_msat: 100099800 ➜ 346846500
770238x1242x0 [JayhawkPleb|0230e8b298bef620df9640c7a956106f905dbc48d5cedadd5837f3a22a9cdced28]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 2250000000 ➜ 3118500000
808648x1876x1 [NoVa_Helo_Bubba|02327617d2b6b397450dba550bd61f6fe1e4586af07b61af636211588b958f3e74]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 80000 ➜ 7920
770859x999x0 [Frode-lightning|023bdd219b85d02da9b3fd679b32a1098c97122767433eb4ba59641514bbcbd694]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 200000000 ➜ 9900
813369x973x1 [MerchantConnectHUB|023e09c43b215bd3dbf483bcb409da3322ea5ea3b046f74698b89ee9ea785dd30a]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 62
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
786488x653x1 [CoinGate|0242a4ae0c5bef18048fbecf995094b74bfb0f7391418d71ed394784373f41e4f3]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 2500005000 ➜ 3465007000
811236x1782x1 [chilman|0242c1650f320c43f3600ebf3b5fcaf566760fcd421f35b68fd1e39a31b29ef540]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 93
max_htlc_msat: 2500000000 ➜ 3465000000
786752x1131x1 [LN.SIDESHIFT.AI|02459b759a62bc3ebfe98a320da237944cc4f35456384bd8fdefa7d0340c75f46f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 750000 ➜ 74250
766030x1287x0 [Los|0256bf97644dd1d839aadd76e2351c1b6bb8173bb9f5ea4affb07075f880e52302]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 40
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
812524x502x1 [wobloz|025e9497188d33af48bb15cfc3cd6d7c549eed05b5f54d45615d3cb7ec3b562588]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 109
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
769802x1805x1 [028ed7bd6ba6763cf040|028ed7bd6ba6763cf040869681890bf5bf95d623108a60e75d76a57f5d637be3ef]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 2500000000 ➜ 3465000000
811244x647x0 [goblin-no.de|02a0f17d3ddb81b3b0c048956baebdf68468c9d7c8b851e5d26354a64a54cff562]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 145
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
811371x990x1 [austen-pushkin|02a2106a4681d68080cf3d8a3b706d6925142aee0caf99302e481dbb08feabfa1a]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 80
max_htlc_msat: 1500000000 ➜ 5197500000
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 40000000 ➜ 7920000
768086x545x1 [Block Crusher|02ab1fbe10650d06f0b94fb4f61d7c4d189b8b0a9f818ea1a9b49667e95a768821]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 0
max_htlc_msat: 1250000000 ➜ 1732500000
813229x358x1 [Azteco|02abfbe63425b1ba4f245af72a0a85ba16cd13365704655b2abfc13e53ad338e02]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
728929x2127x0 [Sovereign Speak|02b18040bdacb30cb0df8db6949cf447fae29d9342999a7dc2b73c2a917fc65a79]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 24
max_htlc_msat: 1500000000 ➜ 2078999999
770256x803x1 [8DegreesWO|02b21ca992bf95e3f324302265ad86cec24f36166fd7afca44efa0809aaa8b25c5]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 2250000000 ➜ 3118500000
769102x1787x1 [NNN|02baf137993ae5da2ba45094e52b4ccf72588b059d32a7401c9759a42d9b68f114]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 70
max_htlc_msat: 8386482000 ➜ 11623664500
770385x2632x0 [Rob|02de5965c0de62f0a3a6464b7c1848510661d43df96caba5e868ed7520cc3fa437]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 1
max_htlc_msat: 1000000000 ➜ 1386000000
772652x1430x1 [Kraken 🐙⚡|02f1a8c87607f415c8f22c00593002775941dea48869ce23096af27b0cfdcc0b69]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 30000000 ➜ 29700
819400x4180x1 [WCC-BOUNCER|02f4c77dcf12255ccf705c18b8d6b95e4f884910bf61e8aa21242607193a79da1b]
policy: new-canal de 2j -> 5j medium-recover-cost
strategy: cost
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 840
803131x1502x1 [LottiBull|0308bd7d969a520ee2753b3e1eb38b1e3615cfdc372485caf521f8db293d5f32c1]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 56415 ➜ 5585
784169x1104x0 [PhoqueDeBussy|031bd7ba713274fedd625103d2bd0e339563b9bbfcbd140dc6a606f3b798542467]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 200000 ➜ 19800
799591x324x1 [BitcoinMX 21M|031ea699f2f5e657473fd14302d00ea8018c67fa83403810544f5bd227b1cd2c41]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 78
max_htlc_msat: 800000000 ➜ 2772000000
799489x248x1 [FranksNODE|032141e1142e05ea53fd7621b13c25db63a1e84102d7df18685024be4ad2dd5ca3]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 38
max_htlc_msat: 800000000 ➜ 2772000000
809618x2972x0 [domesticblend|032b09fb582a7a0718a606ee075598b0ed2e04da376382db03d76aded6e56216c6]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 1500000000 ➜ 2078999999
810359x2574x0 [OverDrive|032d35946ccc4b303dd57836ad10ec1f95a0bac91c0c07f2f20d8445da939ff04e]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 2000000000 ➜ 495000000
811252x626x1 [GeldBoerse|032f46d1e9a0c0db99cf788ddfd86d815be6e9d752af37f4cef5a13a5276af7004]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 74
max_htlc_msat: 1500000000 ➜ 5197500000
783032x921x1 [xmrk|033878501f9a4ce97dba9a6bba4e540eca46cb129a322eb98ea1749ed18ab67735]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50
max_htlc_msat: 2777777500 ➜ 3849999999
812524x700x0 [Garlic🧄|033b63e4a9931dc151037acbce12f4f8968c86f5655cf102bbfa85a26bd4adc6d9]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 70
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
730402x2295x1 [bfx-lnd0|033d8656219478701227199cbd6f670335c8d408a92ae88b962c49d4dc0e83e025]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 610000 ➜ 60390
791861x2577x1 [⚡️MasterYoda⚡|033dee9c6a0afc40ffd8f27d68ef260f3e5e1c19e59c6f9bb607fb04c1d497a809]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 72
max_htlc_msat: 4000000000 ➜ 5544000000
743894x1152x0 [PEEVEDSOUFFLE|0348de9c879470b67bb0c0aab02f1cc945b1bbab8fd87ec4349ba6d0d0a8ac97c0]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 21
max_htlc_msat: 250000000 ➜ 346500000
767259x696x0 [🗲 Greasedlightning 🗲|0351fabd839e93962826ab8eff7f86795b66b7295a2330773938d409a725aa8176]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 64
max_htlc_msat: 2500000000 ➜ 3465000000
811244x1555x0 [WalletOfSatoshi.com|035e4ff418fc8b5554c5d9eea66396c227bd429a3251c8cbc711002ba215bfc226]
policy: specific-nodes
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 372
806376x2004x22[LQwD-Canada|0364913d18a19c671bb36dd04d6ad5be0fe8f2894314c36a9db3f03c2d414907e1]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 200000 ➜ 19800
811704x2659x1 [Orange Sunrise|037943defcf3068fc5b8a2b821cdd2c4c1b1faa39d6a971b3fd984b9dd291a4817]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 1000000 ➜ 19800000
727596x1978x1 [sparkseer.space / lnnodeinsight|0382b31dcff337311bf919411c5073c9c9a129890993f94f4a16eaaeffd91c7788]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 73
max_htlc_msat: 1000000000 ➜ 3465000000
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 510000 ➜ 50490
810807x2639x1 [tankman|0386d289121dc56f2b295c6dc8c7d0e4a7b3eb6d9b6b737a169b6360a81b9e9279]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 82
max_htlc_msat: 2000000000 ➜ 6930000000
809630x812x0 [TPF_CLN|03b8d3617af7a3b525f2ca3cad9d08cae6ff7519a19c9cf3236b3b4e2f092087f4]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 73
max_htlc_msat: 600000000 ➜ 2078999999
812523x1413x2 [Yankee Hotel Foxtrot|03d6f80df785288de2fe5de19f24ba8a1db3d20647a88d0a903be9de3e7bb8fce1]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 50 ➜ 85
max_htlc_msat: 5000000000 ➜ 6930000000
804951x1129x0 [<script>alert("LDK");</script>|03db10aa09ff04d3568b0621750794063df401e6853c79a21a83e1a3f3b5bfb0c8]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 50000000 ➜ 247500000
729144x2302x0 [TheSovereignNode|03ded19c55ab1726e2b839e006321c002c61602cced485c75db895ec73fb48543a]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 72
max_htlc_msat: 400000000 ➜ 1386000000
811604x2935x1 [bitmax|03e121fa397cb7ec60935c140bfbfa7690c3158ba6df26b8bc636508d8a3735afd]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 1000000 ➜ 19800000
805674x2868x0 [BTC Nigeria|03e86afe389d298f8f53a2f09fcc4d50cdd34e2fbd8f32cbd55583c596413705c2]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 40000000 ➜ 7920000
774990x731x0 [Fi4free|03eb9f088f62bb414b74b11e287624d5f05fd92b582658b47b4ed6048e0dd01404]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
max_htlc_msat: 1000000 ➜ 19800000
770484x1645x1 [AliensTech|03f2005837649dd49811bbb7e78993581da41c09d3bdcbc6933492276acccd8b6d]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
fee_ppm: 100 ➜ 72
max_htlc_msat: 600000000 ➜ 2078999999

Execution time: 06-12-2023 14:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 15:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 16:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 17:00:01
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 50490
804951x1129x0 [<script>alert("LDK");</script>|03db10aa09ff04d3568b0621750794063df401e6853c79a21a83e1a3f3b5bfb0c8]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 247500000
774990x731x0 [Fi4free|03eb9f088f62bb414b74b11e287624d5f05fd92b582658b47b4ed6048e0dd01404]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000

Execution time: 06-12-2023 18:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 19:00:01
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 42
max_htlc_msat: 346846500
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 7920000
819400x4180x1 [WCC-BOUNCER|02f4c77dcf12255ccf705c18b8d6b95e4f884910bf61e8aa21242607193a79da1b]
policy: new-canal de 2j -> 5j medium-recover-cost
strategy: cost
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 840
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 50490
809630x812x0 [TPF_CLN|03b8d3617af7a3b525f2ca3cad9d08cae6ff7519a19c9cf3236b3b4e2f092087f4]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 73
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999
804951x1129x0 [<script>alert("LDK");</script>|03db10aa09ff04d3568b0621750794063df401e6853c79a21a83e1a3f3b5bfb0c8]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 247500000
774990x731x0 [Fi4free|03eb9f088f62bb414b74b11e287624d5f05fd92b582658b47b4ed6048e0dd01404]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000

Execution time: 06-12-2023 20:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 21:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 22:00:01

Execution time: 06-12-2023 23:00:01

Execution time: 07-12-2023 00:00:01
784622x343x0 [i'llTryAnythingOnce|020d1617e27ac022395352f2b3774969593d3d6ddff6fb117d820a9dda8da45217]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 106
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
804940x2112x0 [node on the boat⛵|02103f1826be6287c8430e653de06ef16d94b3106c01937a78f5ae2c89bd40f234]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 49500
799390x1545x1 [DorianIsMySatoshi|021d2436cab847373a4212bf6d754ead5304f5d0791479643893a837b295f3441c]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 82
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
774054x1868x0 [Vcleat|02309e1f15f0f4d9e982514dee2c14a9ff914ba8d47b51549a4e22099c314a01be]
policy: petits-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 42
max_htlc_msat: 346846500
811236x1782x1 [chilman|0242c1650f320c43f3600ebf3b5fcaf566760fcd421f35b68fd1e39a31b29ef540]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 93
max_htlc_msat: 3465000000
812825x204x1 [Erebor Mining Co.|02a8d15c6611e9742d64b9f07b91d8f2811399704c296083bb423ae4dd23bddacf]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 7920000
819400x4180x1 [WCC-BOUNCER|02f4c77dcf12255ccf705c18b8d6b95e4f884910bf61e8aa21242607193a79da1b]
policy: new-canal de 2j -> 5j medium-recover-cost
strategy: cost
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 840
810359x2574x0 [OverDrive|032d35946ccc4b303dd57836ad10ec1f95a0bac91c0c07f2f20d8445da939ff04e]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 495000000
767259x696x0 [🗲 Greasedlightning 🗲|0351fabd839e93962826ab8eff7f86795b66b7295a2330773938d409a725aa8176]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 64
max_htlc_msat: 3465000000
806376x2004x22[LQwD-Canada|0364913d18a19c671bb36dd04d6ad5be0fe8f2894314c36a9db3f03c2d414907e1]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800
729961x2990x1 [ACINQ|03864ef025fde8fb587d989186ce6a4a186895ee44a926bfc370e2c366597a3f8f]
policy: canaux-vidés
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 50490
809630x812x0 [TPF_CLN|03b8d3617af7a3b525f2ca3cad9d08cae6ff7519a19c9cf3236b3b4e2f092087f4]
policy: moyens-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 73
max_htlc_msat: 2078999999
812523x1413x2 [Yankee Hotel Foxtrot|03d6f80df785288de2fe5de19f24ba8a1db3d20647a88d0a903be9de3e7bb8fce1]
policy: gros-noeuds
strategy: proportional
channel status: enabled
fee_ppm: 85
max_htlc_msat: 6930000000
804951x1129x0 [<script>alert("LDK");</script>|03db10aa09ff04d3568b0621750794063df401e6853c79a21a83e1a3f3b5bfb0c8]
policy: low-outbound-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 247500000
774990x731x0 [Fi4free|03eb9f088f62bb414b74b11e287624d5f05fd92b582658b47b4ed6048e0dd01404]
policy: drained-canal-prevent-failed-routing
strategy: ignore_fees
channel status: enabled
max_htlc_msat: 19800000

[chmeulblu]

itself too

i happens too often. and the only changes i ve done is to run charge-lnd every hour. is it too often ? does lnd notices i am changing stuff that i shouldn't ? something ?

[accumulator]

No this all looks pretty normal

[chmeulblu]

OK...
it does works . the logic is good. i appreciate charge-lnd it makes a lot of sense.
But channels get disable a lot. and after not very long on both sides. if it is LND disabling channels... it is quite knew and has to be linked o Charge-lnd's behavior somehow. do you know what bothers LND when charge-lnd runs ? i use umbrel could that be clue ? do you have advices on how to minimize impact on LND ( more use of maxhltc , less use fees ? ) .