juraj-hrivnak / underdog

Minecraft modpack centred around realism, exploration, survival, and ecology.

About

Underdog is a modpack for Minecraft Java Edition that makes the game realistic in every possible way.

Releases are available on CurseForge or here on GitHub! Modpack must be imported to a launcher to install correctly.

---

Development

To download the latest development build, click here.

For the set-up guide, please head over to the CONTRIBUTING.md.

Knowledge of Git is required. If installing/removing/updating mods, knowledge of PAX is required.

Also, after setting up the pack, take a look into the ./pax folder. This folder contains all the development tools required when exporting the pack.

underdog's Issues

Biome fog starts to flicker when it starts to rain on server

Description

Probably it's DSurround's + Weather2's fault.
It needs investigation, though.

The latest.log file

https://mclo.gs/CVKFKqK

Underdog version

3.2.0

Launcher

MultiMC

OS

Windows

Fishing Made Better startup crash

Describe the bug

Changing certain controls from in-game causes the modpack to stop launching successfully on subsequent launches, due to an error with Fishing Made Better

- To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behaviour:
Please refer to the attached options.txt file for a complete list of keybind changes, which is left-hand friendly
options.txt

Expected behaviour

The game should launch correctly and arrive at Minecraft's main menu screen

Screenshots

Additional context

Switching the main hand to the left hand does not affect the modpack's ability to launch
Both altering and not-altering Fishing Made Better keybinds does not inherently affect the modpack's ability to launch

• Relevant crash report:
  crash-2022-04-18_20.23.06-client.txt

Add more guidebook entries

Add more guidebook entries

• Mechanics of gravity & collapses
• Proper nutrition & seasons

CurseForge launcher uses seven years old java by default, which with AMD GPU, causes a crash at pre-initialization

Describe the bug
During Pre-Initialization, a mod causes graphics drivers to crash, causing a black screen for a few seconds while the drivers reboot/enter safemode. The bug seems to be caused by the mod Endertech Forge (I might have the name wrong, I am most sure of the words Ender and Forge, but am unsure about the word tech.) or something set to pre-initialize right after it.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

• 1. Launch the pack
• 2. The pack will begin loading as normal.
• 3. when pre-initializing the mod "Endertech Forge" (or something set to load right after), The screen freezes, then goes dark.
• 4. Upon Re-initialization of graphics drivers, the Minecraft window will be frozen. with a white screen

Expected behavior
The expected behavior is that pre-initialization and the rest of loading continues as normal, or at the very least throws a readable error.

Screenshots

The Minecraft window is frozen completely white, and cannot be moved.

Additional context
My computer runs the Radeon RX 570 Series GPU, and has 8 Gigs of ram.

Mob Agression is set incorrectly

as we talked in discord, the mob aggression is set too high.

List of passive mobs (by entity id) that are made "neutral" like wolves.

# You may put a tilde (~) in front of any entity id to make it specific; specific entity ids
# will not count any entities extending (i.e., based on) the specified entity.
# Additional number after the entity id is the chance (

Additional number after the entity id is the chance (0.0 to 1.0) for entities of that type to spawn with the AI.

valid levels are 0.00 - 1.00 = 100 levels
if your wanting a 10% chance then a animal would need 0.10
a 1% chance would be 0.01

this means
animania:rooster_leghorn 0.7
animania:rooster_orpington 0.7
animania:rooster_plymouth_rock 0.7
animania:rooster_rhode_island_red 0.7
animania:rooster_wyandotte 0.7
thats 70% chance
for the mob to be aggressive.

horse_colors:horse_felinoid 0.3
thats 30% chance for aggressive

:) hope it helps :) cause i hate getting beaten up by roosters :)

EDIT: my derp, the % chance is for being passive.. so its a 70% chance to be passive, 30% to be aggressive. which is still higher than you planned..

Milk turns into water when using a bottle

Describe the bug
Holstein milk put in a hole in ground becomes water when filling glass bottle

• To Reproduce
  put milk in hole. Click on it with glass bottle

crashed world?

trying to attach

Slimeballs need a workaround

• So far, slimeballs are not possible to farm because slimes have been removed.
  This would need to be fixed by either adding slimes back or using resin as slimeballs.

Rendering block entity crash

Description

I seemingly crashed at random while moving my crosshair fairly quickly across a few blocks in my base. This occurred 3 separate times in one session.

The latest.log file

https://mclo.gs/eNNkAMA

Underdog version

v.3.4.1

Launcher

Prism Launcher

OS

Windows

Animated textures won't work with Optifine installed

Describe the bug

The streams water along with the pyrotech firepit fire is not animated whatsoever.

• To Reproduce
  Steps to reproduce the behaviour:

1. Find stream mod streams - view unanimated water
2. Place logpile in standard format for pit burning and ignite - view unanimated fire
   Expected behaviour

Stream water and fire to be animated.
Screenshots

Additional context

Cobblestone slabs not working

Describe the bug

• To Reproduce
  Steps to reproduce the behaviour: Right click the stone slab on the item, and if in the space, it won't do anything, but if you do the same without being in the block space, it places the item instead.

Expected behaviour

Screenshots

**Additional cont
![Pit Kiln](https://u
![Refractory Kiln-stone slab outside](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/75522057/148662972-121e771c-51a7-47d3-af54-f5
![Refractory Kil

n-stone slab](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/75522057/148662974-7106092b-c254-4567-95dc-72a787e54783.png)
7faa84233d.png)
ser-images.githubusercontent.com/75522057/148662967-22251bd1-1b61-4b5d-9d61-74270afec5de.png)
ext**

F&E server crash

Stonecutter (FutureMC) creates vanilla stone slabs for free

Description

Per title- without any input materials, you can create an unlimited amount of vanilla stone slabs, 2 at a time.

The latest.log file

N/a

Underdog version

3.1.1

Launcher

CurseForge

OS

Windows

Clay bucket milk use

Using clay bucket to get milk from cow is not usable without forestry bottler. There are no recipes to use it.

Recipes should be similar to those for iron bucket. This would make clay bucket more useful before iron is produced.

Custom stones messed up with snow

Wood slabs not working

Wooden slabs not going into the kiln/crucible

• To Reproduce
  Steps to reproduce the behaviour: Try to place the slab into the kiln/crucible, within block space or step back a block space and right click to either show that it doesn't go into it at all, or to place it in world instead, respectively.

Expected behaviour

Screenshots

**Additiona

l context**

Add more quest descriptions

Cuisine

• Wokking
• Fruit Press
• Drinkro
• Chopping board
• Mortar
• Wooden Arm

Refractory

• Bloomery
  • Bellows
  • Tongs, Hammer & Anvil
• Refractory Crucible
  • Casting
• Blast Furnace

ClientTicks queue overflow freeze/crash

Description

While performing typical gameplay and re-activating a faucet after taking an ingot out of the smeltery, my instance completely froze up.

*08/11
It can happen multiple times during gameplay, but from what I've noticed, it only occurs in my tinker's construct area. Oddly, the issue doesn't appear to affect my friend who is nearby. The additional mod I have added is the SerializationIsBad mod and the mod I disabled is OptionsEnforcer.

The latest.log file

https://mclo.gs/WdirC4X

Underdog version

v.3.4.1

Launcher

Prism Launcher

OS

Windows

Some lumber replacements do not work

Affected recipes

Forestry machines and probably others.

Underdog version

3.4.0

Description (Optional)

The solution is possible with the usage of GroovyScript.

The crafttweaker.log file (Optional)

No response

Limestone Chunks not treated as rock?

Limestone can't do things like make furnaces.
Are they supposed to not be considered rocksHard?

Salt & Fresh water

Saltwater instead of water & Freshwater instead of purrified water.

Add regular/salt water ice

• Regular water
• Saltwater
• Add a basic world generation for ice

Tweaked petroleum config required

By default Tweaked petroleum removes IP reservoir loading, this is intended behavior but was poorly expand.
The cf page has be updated to reflect that and i have created a starting template, the configs are equivalent to IP's

Dynamic Darkness causes extreme lag

The latest version (0.4.2) of Dynamic Darkness causes excessive amounts of lag. yamporg/mods#40
Downgrading to 0.2.1 fixes the issue

Missing replacement for end & nether stuff...

• Ender pearls

• Blaze rods can't be obtained. They will need to be replaced with something.

• Blaze powder will be replaced with Sulphur.

• Glowstone will be replaced with Phosphorus.

• Netherite will be replaced with Gabro.

• Endstone will be probably retextured and used as some mineral or stone. Probably dolomite.

• Other stuff like chorus plants are still unknown what to do with them.

• The first two ones are pretty urgent. So they will be replaced in future.
  And the other stuff will maybe get replaced in future

serene seasons in simple difficulty temperatures feel not enough

we talked about this is discord,

I believe the temps in summer spring are not high enough.
I was still cold in the summer without anything on.

and winter as i mentioned is too warm for wearing more than 1-2 parts of the winter gear

Blue square on rocks

Client

• MultiMC

Operating System

• Windows

Latest.log

https://sharetext.me/7orcfnxpfd)

Describe the bug
blue square on rocks, when break there are particle effect pop out (unlike not squared one)

Underdog GUI Textures Failing to Load

Describe the bug
The textures for the Underdog gui are missing in game, causing the magenta and black 'texture' to appear. Java cannot locate them despite being in the mod pack folder

• To Reproduce
  Extracting the Underdog pack override into installation, then launching minecraft.

Expected behaviour
Java should be able to find the files present in the \oresources\modpack\textures\gui' folder and display the gui

Screenshots

Additional context
debug.log
latest.log
In the debug it says that it fails to locate the texture in the specified path.

Flint, clay, and bone shears are inaccessible

Affected recipes

Every recipe using Pyrotech stone rods

Underdog version

3.4.0

Description (Optional)

No response

The crafttweaker.log file (Optional)

No response

Game crashes when trying to join the server

Description

tried to join the server and game crashed

Reproduction steps

a

Screenshots

No response

The latest.log file

https://gist.github.com/Saamioo/7c22b939727ec95c9782f9b9a6007644

Launcher

CurseForge

OS

Windows

Idea suggestion - Food related

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

No problem to report, i'm just getting started, this is just a suggestion based on the motto "will this make sense in real life ?" I see in my early game that food can be stocked in a chest and stay as good as fresh for days, weeks even. It will not make sense in real life right ?

Describe the solution you'd like.

I guess it will change some of the gameplay quite a bit in the early game (hunting what you will eat today) but i'll suggest an ''expiration'' system for food, maybe based on the ''Spice of life'' classification (protein expires faster than vegs), and maybe based on the cointainer the food is placed in (if it's a wooden chest or a fridge, or another container...). I'll be glad if the gameplay changed items into ''rotten food'' every time you're not eating it right away, or in 5, 10 days depending on the food and container.

Describe alternatives you've considered.

(I don't know if any mods proposes this feature right now and maybe it will be necessary to make it compatible... and i'm certainly not asking you to create a mod on your own, buuuuut....)

Additional context

Love playing the pack tho !

Underdog version

3.5.2

Ores not generating

Describe the bug
It seems as though ores from most mods are not generating.

To Reproduce
When mining, I have not been able to find any ores such as iron or copper. I have tried going into spectator and creative mode to search but have been unable to find any ores.

Expected behavior
I expected to be able to find copper and aluminum to make things like the hatch in the mod charcoal pit.

(Side note: I just got github so if I'm not doing this right please tell me)
@juraj-hrivnak

Add Options Enforcer instead of Default Options

Options Enforcer can replace the option every time user launches the pack.
This is very useful for resource pack loading.

Immersive Engineering Blast Furnace Fuel Compatibility

Affected recipes

Blast Furnace Fuel

Underdog version

v.3.4.1

Description (Optional)

Attempting to place a Pyrotech Charcoal (pyrotech:charcoal_block) in the fuel slot for the IE Blast Furnace will not work as it does not accept any of the fuel sources except for the ones listed in the screenshot.
e.g.

• Coal Coke (fuelCoke from IE)
• Block of Coal Coke (blockFuelCoke, blockCoalCoke from IE/Chisel)
• Charcoal (charcoal, itemcharcoal from Minecraft)
• Block of Charcoal (blockCharcoal from Forestry)
  

The crafttweaker.log file (Optional)

No response

Special AI config typo

in the special AI config
Special_AI.cfg

"animania:cow_mooshroom -- a0.3" is what is there. I believe you means to make just 0.3 not a0.3

Treated sticks can't be crafted.

The recipe for normal sticks can use treated lumber as an ingredient and takes priority over the recipe for treated sticks.

Weird tree gen

Description

The latest.log file

no need

Underdog version

3.4.1

Launcher

Prism Launcher

OS

Windows

Thermal Foundation needs a workaround

• So far, a lot of Thermal foundation items can't be crafted.
  This will need to be fixed in future.

Some metal blocks are not craftable

Affected recipes

Iron block and others

Underdog version

3.1.1

Description (Optional)

No response

The crafttweaker.log file (Optional)

No response

Incorrect chimney recipe output

When making a chimney with limestone chunks, the recipe output is a granite cobblestone chimney.
I would expect a limestone cobble chimney.

Pyrotech's Coal Coke block is not a valid fuel in the IE's Blast Furnace

Describe the bug
PyroTech's Coal Coke block is not a valid fuel in the Immersive Engineering Blast Furnace

Steps to reproduce the behaviour:
Refractory Burning produces IE Coal Coke, which can be compressed in the Mechanical Compactor into a block form, in which it becomes Pyrotech Coal Coke.

Expected behaviour
If the BF accepts IE's Coal Coke item as a valid fuel then it'd be expected that Pyrotech's Coal Coke block would also be valid as well.

Screenshots

Pyrotech's Coal Coke block can't be used (notice the red overlay on the slots when using SHIFT)

Immersive Engineering's Coal Coke block is a valid item for the fuel slot (cheated in to test)

Additional context
Underdog v3.0.1

Tree Growth might feel better being sped up some.

i did change the tree growth to 4x what you had.. it was on .5 i made it 2.0 its feeling like trees are taking forever to grow.. and normally you can plant and get a full tree on vanilla in a bit.. its been 2-3 seasons now for some trees

will let you know feedback more on how that feels soon/update

Rustic Grapes don't have the middle section visible

Describe the bug
Rustic Grapes don't have the middle section visible, though the hitbox is there.

• To Reproduce
  Grow a grape.

Expected behaviour
Grappe block in the middle.

Screenshots