kevinyzy / seckilldesign

秒杀与抢购系统架构设计与实现

zd 置顶 Java秒杀与抢购模型的架构设计与实现

开发环境:

IntelliJ IDEA + Maven + Workbench

压测工具:

JMeter

使用框架:

Spring Boot + Mybatis + Redis + RabbitMQ

具体内容:

对高并发高负载情形下的应用场景进行分析，以高效地处理资源竞争为目的，设计一个秒杀与抢购模型。
本项目提供了三种解决方案来比较系统的性能：
1.利用MySQL的update行锁实现悲观锁。
2.MySQL加字段version实现乐观锁。
3.基于AtomicInteger的CAS机制；
4.使用Redis作为原子计数器（watch事务+decr操作），RabbitMQ作为消息队列记录用户抢购行为，MySQL做异步存储。
上述四个解决方案均使用了JMeter进行压力与性能测试（实验设置的是10秒内产生3000个请求），分析其吞吐量、平均响应时间、错误率等参数，最后得出相应结论。

实验结果:

实验结果表明：
四种方案的响应错误率均为零，但是吞吐量不一样，
总体来说第一种和第四种方案的吞吐量相当，平均响应时间也较快；
第三种方案的吞吐量慢于上述两种，CAS机制效果不错。
第二种方案的响应时间最慢，原因是高并发情形下多个线程不断回滚，耗费了大量的CPU资源，导致性能低下。

备注:

1.此项目包含了sql文件，包括表单创建和添加数据。
2.包含了JMeter配置图片与实验结果图片
3.包含了测试数据集：param.txt。第一个参数代表用户ID，第二个参数代表产品ID。

核心代码：

MySQL悲观锁

@Transactional
public SecKillEnum handleByPessLockInMySQL(Map<String, Object> paramMap) {
    Jedis jedis = redisCacheHandle.getJedis();
    Record record = null;
    Integer userId = (Integer) paramMap.get("userId");
    Integer productId = (Integer)paramMap.get("productId");
    User user = new User(userId);
    Product product = secKillMapper.getProductById(productId);
    String hasBoughtSetKey = SecKillUtils.getRedisHasBoughtSetKey(product.getProductName());

    //判断是否重复购买
    boolean isBuy = jedis.sismember(hasBoughtSetKey, user.getId().toString());
    if (isBuy){
        //重复秒杀
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }
    boolean secKillSuccess = secKillMapper.updatePessLockInMySQL(product);
    if (!secKillSuccess){
        //库存不足
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.LOW_STOCKS);
    }

    //秒杀成功
    record = new Record(null,user,product,SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getCode(),SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getMessage(),new Date());
    log.info(record.toString());
    boolean insertFlag =  secKillMapper.insertRecord(record);
    //插入record成功
    if (insertFlag){
        long addResult = jedis.sadd(hasBoughtSetKey,user.getId().toString());
        if (addResult>0){
            log.info("---------秒杀成功");
            return SecKillEnum.SUCCESS;
        }else {
            throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
        }
    }else {
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.SYSTEM_EXCEPTION);
    }
}

MySQL乐观锁

@Transactional
public SecKillEnum handleByPosiLockInMySQL(Map<String, Object> paramMap){
    Jedis jedis = redisCacheHandle.getJedis();
    Record record = null;
    Integer userId = (Integer) paramMap.get("userId");
    Integer productId = (Integer)paramMap.get("productId");
    User user = new User(userId);
    Product product = secKillMapper.getProductById(productId);
    String hasBoughtSetKey = SecKillUtils.getRedisHasBoughtSetKey(product.getProductName());

    //判断是否重复购买
    boolean isBuy = jedis.sismember(hasBoughtSetKey, user.getId().toString());
    if (isBuy){
        //重复秒杀
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }
    //库存减一
    int lastStock = product.getStock()-1;
    if (lastStock>=0){
        product.setStock(lastStock);
        boolean secKillSuccess = secKillMapper.updatePosiLockInMySQL(product);
        if (!secKillSuccess){
            //秒杀失败,version被修改
            throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.FAIL);
        }
    }else {
        //库存不足
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.LOW_STOCKS);
    }

    record = new Record(null,user,product,SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getCode(),SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getMessage(),new Date());
    log.info(record.toString());
    boolean insertFlag = secKillMapper.insertRecord(record);
    //插入record成功
    if (insertFlag){
        long addResult = jedis.sadd(hasBoughtSetKey,user.getId().toString());
        if (addResult>0){
            //秒杀成功
            return SecKillEnum.SUCCESS;
        }else {
            //重复秒杀
            log.info("---------重复秒杀");
            throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
        }
    }else {
        //系统错误
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.SYSTEM_EXCEPTION);
    }
}

redis的watch监控

public SecKillEnum handleByRedisWatch(Map<String, Object> paramMap) {
    Jedis jedis = redisCacheHandle.getJedis();
    Record record = null;
    Integer userId = (Integer) paramMap.get("userId");
    Integer productId = (Integer)paramMap.get("productId");
    User user = new User(userId);
    String productName = jedis.get("product_"+productId);
    String productStockCacheKey = productName+"_stock";
    String hasBoughtSetKey = SecKillUtils.getRedisHasBoughtSetKey(productName);

    //watch开启监控
    jedis.watch(productStockCacheKey);

    //判断是否重复购买，注意这里高并发情形下并不安全
    boolean isBuy = jedis.sismember(hasBoughtSetKey, user.getId().toString());
    if (isBuy){
        //重复秒杀
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }

    String stock = jedis.get(productStockCacheKey);
    if (Integer.parseInt(stock)<=0) {
        //库存不足
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.LOW_STOCKS);
    }

    //开启Redis事务
    Transaction tx = jedis.multi();
    //库存减一
    tx.decrBy(productStockCacheKey,1);
    //执行事务
    List<Object> resultList = tx.exec();

    if (resultList == null || resultList.isEmpty()) {
        jedis.unwatch();
        //watch监控被更改过----物品抢购失败;
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.FAIL);
    }

    //添加到已买队列
    long addResult = jedis.sadd(hasBoughtSetKey,user.getId().toString());
    if (addResult>0){
        Product product = new Product(productId);
        //秒杀成功
        record =  new Record(null,user,product,SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getCode(),SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getMessage(),new Date());
        //添加record到rabbitMQ消息队列
        rabbitMQSender.send(JSON.toJSONString(record));
        //返回秒杀成功
        return SecKillEnum.SUCCESS;
    }else {
        //重复秒杀
        //这里抛出RuntimeException异常，redis的decr操作并不会回滚，所以需要手动incr回去
        jedis.incrBy(productStockCacheKey,1);
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }
}

AtomicInteger的CAS机制

@Transactional
public SecKillEnum handleByAtomicInteger(Map<String, Object> paramMap) {
    Jedis jedis = redisCacheHandle.getJedis();
    Record record;

    Integer userId = (Integer) paramMap.get("userId");
    Integer productId = (Integer)paramMap.get("productId");
    User user = secKillMapper.getUserById(userId);
    Product product = secKillMapper.getProductById(productId);

    String hasBoughtSetKey = SecKillUtils.getRedisHasBoughtSetKey(product.getProductName());
    //判断是否重复购买
    boolean isBuy = jedis.sismember(hasBoughtSetKey, user.getId().toString());
    if (isBuy){
        log.error("用户:"+user.getUsername()+"重复购买商品"+product.getProductName());
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }

    AtomicInteger atomicInteger = atomicStock.getAtomicInteger(product.getProductName());
    int stock = atomicInteger.decrementAndGet();

    if (stock < 0) {
        log.error("商品:"+product.getProductName()+"库存不足, 抢购失败!");
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.LOW_STOCKS);
    }


    long result = jedis.sadd(hasBoughtSetKey,user.getId().toString());
    if (result > 0){
        record = new Record(null,user,product,SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getCode(),SecKillEnum.SUCCESS.getMessage(),new Date());
        log.info(record.toString());
        boolean insertFlag =  secKillMapper.insertRecord(record);
        if (insertFlag) {
            //更改物品库存
            secKillMapper.updateByAsynPattern(record.getProduct());
            log.info("用户:"+user.getUsername()+"秒杀商品"+product.getProductName()+"成功!");
            return SecKillEnum.SUCCESS;
        } else {
            log.error("系统错误!");
            throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.SYSTEM_EXCEPTION);
        }
    } else {
        log.error("用户:"+user.getUsername()+"重复秒杀商品"+product.getProductName());
        atomicInteger.incrementAndGet();
        throw new SecKillException(SecKillEnum.REPEAT);
    }
}

JMeter压测图片:

实验结果图片:

MySQL悲观锁

#####################################################################

MySQL乐观锁

#####################################################################

redis的watch监控

#####################################################################

AtomicInteger的CAS机制