Return members in the same given order about pytkdocs

[ofek]

Hello again! Has this been fixed/implemented?

[pawamoy]

8 months later...

No 😕
PRs welcome. I'm currently reducing the number of open issues to keep the ones we could still implement/fix in pytkdocs (which will be replaced by a more robust tool).

[ofek]

@pawamoy Hmm, I see your preferred solution but wouldn't it make more sense to have the renderer read the members and act accordingly? Especially since the renderer has since added a new sorting option mkdocstrings/mkdocstrings#274

[pawamoy]

@ofek sorry for the late reply 🙇

have the renderer read the members and act accordingly

Unfortunately that is not possible, because mkdocstrings passes the selection options only to the collector, not the renderer. I wouldn't be against a refactor that removes the distinction between these two options groups (no more selection/rendering keys, no more base renderer / base collector classes, just a base handler one that receives all options). Up to the discussion of course.

I'll try to come up with a workaround in the next few days (keeping that issue in my saved notifications).

Also note that I've been working on a new "collector" which might alleviate this issue. I'll try to move forward on this in the next few days as well.

[pawamoy]

This should now be fixed (finally 🥵!), at least with the new Python handler.

[pawamoy]

Ah, but we're in the pytkdocs repo here 🤦
So it's not fixed. But it can now be fixed. Reopening.