PX4 Docker containers about px4-devguide

[hamishwillee]

G'day, I just followed the instructions on this too (my they assume you know a lot about docker) - running inside a Ubuntu 16.04 VM on Windows.

When you say that the makefile directory was present - you mean that you can see it within docker?

I entered near-identical instructions - the main difference being use of sudo and also specified the source tree:

xhost +
sudo docker run -it --privileged \
-v ~/src/Firmware:/src/firmware/:rw \
-v /tmp/.X11-unix:/tmp/.X11-unix:ro \
-e DISPLAY=:0 \
-p 14556:14556/udp \
--name=px4_ros_sim px4io/px4-dev-ros:2017-05-31 bash

When I try build anything I don't get missing Makefile errors ...

make posix_sitl_default gazebo

Instead I get permission denied errors when make tries to create the build directories (followed by recipe fails). Any ideas on that?

[hamishwillee]

PS Just some notes on docs for when/if I come to document this:

1. "Pull one of the tagged images if you're after a container that just works" - how do I get a list of tagged images? Link to an example list
2. The list of containers in our docs does not match github - ie hierarchy here
   • In particular, our docs refer to px4io/px4-dev , but heirarchy does not list this ... e.g. it has px4-dev-nuttx
3. A real example using the normal ~/src/Firmware/ cloning/installation would not hurt. Even a bash script to do everything/set this up.
4. For Linux the docker instructions say that you have to use sudo for all instructions from host. Need to make that clear.

[Stifael]

@hamishwillee

When you say that the makefile directory was present - you mean that you can see it within docker?

Yes. If I am within the docker container px4_ros_sim and go to the directory /src/firmware then I basically can see the normal px4 Firmware directory (including the Makefiel). But I cannot build anything...

Not sure why you get permission denied or even why you should be root.

[hamishwillee]

Not sure why you get permission denied or even why you should be root.

From docker install guide: "You need to use sudo to run Docker commands. Continue to Linux postinstall to allow non-privileged users to run Docker commands and for other optional configuration steps."

Either way, clearly docs broken.

[Stifael]

but make is not a docker command

[hamishwillee]

Sorry, I was unclear. I ran docker itself using sudo (i.e. sudo docker run -it ... - your example doesn't. I think may try to add a group as per docs and see if that changes effect of permissions

[Stifael]

true: this is needed
https://docs.docker.com/engine/installation/linux/linux-postinstall/

[hamishwillee]

Actually it wasn't enough - I still got permission errors. I've just used chmod to give full access to my current user over the host folder (not clear why they didn't have it). Everything building now. Things would probably go smoother if I was better at linux.

[hamishwillee]

Sorry, didn't mean to close! Also, I don't appear to have got closer to helping you.

[Stifael]

@hamishwillee
with sudo docker run ... I also get the permission denied error

[hamishwillee]

@Stifael Don't know if you saw, but Daniel's scripts for CI might be helpful: PX4/PX4-containers#65 (comment)