Global costmap being cleared about strands_navigation

[bfalacerda]

its the clear costmaps recovery that also clears the global costmap. I guess it should be reloaded aftewards but it isn't all the time because of the loading global costmap issue move_base has. Does this happen all the time? I'll remove the clearance from the navigation recovery, this is pretty bad...

[lucasb-eyer]

Twice for now, will watch if it happens the next times too.

[bfalacerda]

anyway, it's clearly a bad idea having it in, at least until we are sure that move_base global costmap loading is working. i'm removing it now

[lucasb-eyer]

I think it's not (only?) the clearing. If I start the system with a no-go map, only the no-go map is used to create a costmap, and I get what you see in above pictures. If I start it without the costmap, the real map is correctly used to create a no-go map.

[bfalacerda]

every time you start it its not loaded?

[bfalacerda]

our no-go map is usually overlaying the original map so maybe there's an issue with the dual static map layer that we weren't aware of. From what I see your no-go only has the "no-go" obstacles right?

[lucasb-eyer]

Yeah, basically a frame around the building. It worked a few days ago as far as I can remember.

[bfalacerda]

this requires a deeper look into the issue then

[bfalacerda]

it never loads or is it only once in a while?

[lucasb-eyer]

I restarted it three times with no-go map off and three times with no-go map on. All the times no-go map was on, the global-costmap only had a halo around the no-go map; all the times no-go map was off, the global-costmap had a halo around the real map.

[bfalacerda]

all the times no-go map was off, the global-costmap had a halo around the real map.

Is this really what you wanted to say? If so I'm confused

[lucasb-eyer]

I think so. More clearly:

• with_nogo=true -> costmap only around nogo map, not around real map, like screenshots above.
• with_nogo=false -> costmap around real map.

[bfalacerda]

ah ok, i misunderstood what you meant with "halo around"

I'll look into it, the easy, non system intrusive fix for now is making your nogo map the nogo areas overlaying the map

[bfalacerda]

i dont really know when/if i'll have time for this before the marathon starts...

[lucasb-eyer]

Looking into it a bit myself, otherwise I'll workaround

[bfalacerda]

you said you remember it working before. were there any changes done to our move base stuff?

[lucasb-eyer]

I really don't know when it was last working because I never actively looked for it anymore after I've last verified it worked sometimes last week.

More debugging: It's the inflation layer, which is only using the /cost_map, not the /map. Why, I don't know yet.

[bfalacerda]

http://wiki.ros.org/hydro/Migration#Navigation_-_Costmap2D

I followed this when we migrated to hydro. Not sure of why I did it like that anyomre

[bfalacerda]

the lack of inflation layer for the map probably explains why the global planner finds plans through tiny holes in the map though

[lucasb-eyer]

I looked through all tutorials and it looks like the inflation layer should just work on the fully "rendered"/combined costmap, and not on an individual layer, so something is weird. I guess I'll work around for now since time is running out.

[nilsbore]

Wasn't this exactly what @Jailander provided a fix for?

[bfalacerda]

i'll open an issue for later

[bfalacerda]

i dont recall anyone looking at costmap stuff lately but i might have missed it

[bfalacerda]

closing this, we have an open issue here:

strands-project/strands_movebase#27